Head-to-head
New York vs Florida
New York's 2024 price level is 4.507 points above Florida's (107.921 vs 103.414), but their rent price levels are almost identical (122.168 vs 122.107); the gap comes from utilities, goods and New York's income tax.
Updated
| Measure | New York | Florida | First − second |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-items price level | 107.921 | 103.414 | +4.507 points |
| Rent price level | 122.168 | 122.107 | +0.061 points |
| Home value | $423,800±$1,627 | $359,000±$930 | +$64,800 |
| Two-bedroom gross rent | $1,620±$10 | $1,664±$7 | −$44 |
| Household income | $85,974±$402 | $74,568±$284 | +$11,406 |
| Real estate taxes paid | $6,582±$21 | $2,730±$10 | +$3,852 |
$4,000 of monthly spending in New York scales to $3,833 in Florida at the 2024 all-items price ratio.
BEA 2024 and ACS 2020–2024; ± marks the Census 90% margin. How to read a gap
New York vs Florida: same rents, different everything else
Rent is not the difference people expect. The two rent parities are 0.061 points apart, and the two-bedroom gross-rent median is actually $44 higher in Florida, $1,664 against $1,620. Florida renters spend 35.2% of income on gross rent, against 31.2% in New York. The price gap sits elsewhere: utilities are 44.296 points dearer in New York, goods 9.195 points dearer and other services 2.743.
Owners save more in Florida. A typical New York owner pays $3,852 a year more in property tax than a Florida owner, and a mortgaged owner's monthly outlay runs $596 higher. Insurance and association costs, which these statistics leave out, can claw back part of that difference for a Florida purchase.
The income-tax contrast is the headline for most movers. New York's graduated tax has top rates from 9.65% to 10.90% through 2032, New York City adds its own, and individual income tax supplied 46.6% of New York's fiscal 2025 collections, $3,060 per resident. Florida has no personal income tax and relies on general sales for 62.9% of its collections. Total collections were $6,563 per resident in New York and $2,709 in Florida. Moving ends New York resident tax only when New York residency ends, under the domicile and 184-day rules set out below.
New York's income lead is $11,406 at the household median and $7,022 per person after prices.
The two have converged since 2020, when New York stood at 110.130 and Florida at 100.604. Turning an apartment into a purchase needs its own financing and maintenance worksheet.
Price levels by category
| Measure | New York | Florida | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| All items | 107.921 | 103.414 | +4.507 |
| Goods | 107.254 | 98.059 | +9.195 |
| Housing (rents) | 122.168 | 122.107 | +0.061 |
| Utilities | 134.370 | 90.074 | +44.296 |
| Other services | 104.067 | 101.324 | +2.743 |
| Real income per person (2017 $) | $64,153 | $57,131 | +$7,022 |
Two state tax mixes, FY2025
New York: $131.28 billion, $6,563 per resident. Florida: $63.55 billion, $2,709 per resident.
| Tax | NY share | FL share | NY per resident | FL per resident |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Individual income | 46.6% | not levied | $3,060 | — |
| General sales | 15.5% | 62.9% | $1,020 | $1,705 |
| Property | not levied | not levied | — | — |
| Motor fuel | 1.2% | 6.2% | $77 | $169 |
| Other selective sales | 10.3% | 11.1% | $674 | $301 |
| Corporate income | 20.4% | 9.2% | $1,339 | $248 |
| Licenses | 1.5% | 3.9% | $96 | $107 |
| Severance | not levied | 0.0% | — | $1 |
| Other taxes | 4.5% | 6.6% | $297 | $179 |
Taxes on wages and purchases
| Tax | New York | Florida |
|---|---|---|
| Income tax | graduated; top rates 9.65% to 10.90% through 2032; New York City adds its own tax | no personal income tax |
| State sales tax | 4% state rate plus local tax and 0.375% in the MCTD | 6% general state rate |
Leaving New York for Florida: residency rules
Moving to Florida ends New York resident tax only when New York residency ends. New York treats you as a resident if your domicile, your permanent and primary home, is in New York, or if you keep a permanent place of abode there for substantially all of the year and spend 184 days or more in the state. Any part of a day counts as a day, and you do not need to be at the abode for the day to count.
In the year you move, income is split: the resident period is taxed under resident rules and the rest under nonresident rules, which still reach New York-source income such as pay for work performed in the state. New York City applies the same domicile and 184-day tests for its own income tax.
Sources, read : New York Department of Taxation and Finance: residency and nonresident FAQs.
Reviewed by the State Cost Compare Editorial Team · Review policy · Report a correction